SourceL FB, the copyright of the image is with the respective owner.
I’ve read the book (a draft publicly available indeed) carefully and then thought I should write a review:
After watching all the drama in the Parliament where Rahul Gandhi displayed the book Four Stars of Destiny by former Army Chief Manoj Naravane, I became curious. Is the book really controversial? Does it attack the government? Does it expose secrets?
In today’s time, stopping a book is almost impossible anyway — PDFs circulate within hours. So the only meaningful thing is: read first, react later.
Years ago I had read The Polyester Prince, and now this. I decided to take a neutral view and see what the book actually says — not what people claim it says.
What the book actually is
This is not a political book.
This is not even a war-story book.
It is a professional soldier’s life diary mixed with leadership reflections.
Across 430+ pages, General Naravane narrates:
his childhood as a service kid moving across cities and countries
NDA and regimental life
counter-insurgency operations - Government's indecisiveness
staff postings and military bureaucracy
finally — the Army Chief years during COVID and the Ladakh standoff, OROP and how Agineer scheme was diluted.
Interestingly, the foreword and praise come from people across ideological spectrum — military officers, diplomats and even politicians — which itself shows the book is not propaganda oriented.
Does the book target Congress or BJP?
No.
And that is exactly why it is being selectively quoted.
The book does not praise Congress
The book does not glorify BJP, but yes, shows the pain that how babus treat the army. It praises government where it should and question where it is due.
it shows a third reality —
How the military and political system actually function together.
Wherever necessary, it points out friction points, not blame.
Sensitive topics discussed (without sensationalism)
The author describes situations, constraints and decision-making challenges rather than accusing individuals.
1. China and Ladakh crisis
He explains how military response is not just “attack or retreat”.
There are diplomatic layers, escalation risks and global consequences.
Political indecision, caution and signalling all coexist.
This part reads less like accusation and more like:
war in modern era is negotiation backed by force
2. Bureaucracy vs Military
One of the strongest recurring themes:
soldiers plan in hours
files move in months
He explains why procurement delays, approvals and operational restrictions happen — not because someone is anti-army, but because the system is designed around risk-avoidance.
You realise:
India’s defence challenges are administrative more than battlefield.
3. Agniveer, OROP and reforms
The book neither glorifies nor rejects reforms.
Instead it shows a typical reality:
original objective of reform
how implementation changes it as per the people incompetent to make decision and kills the soul and sole purpose of Agniveer
how military adapts anyway - and that's why India cannot become another Pakistan
Very balanced — almost managerial analysis rather than emotional reaction.
The real heart of the book — Leadership
This is where the book becomes valuable even for corporate professionals.
Throughout his career he keeps noting lessons from seniors, mistakes and situations.
Some recurring themes:
Listen to your subordinates — they know ground reality
Authority without empathy breaks units
Promotions don’t make leaders, responsibility does
Crisis exposes systems, not people
Discipline is consistency, not strictness
Luck plays a role but preparedness converts luck into opportunity
He repeatedly shows he learnt more from bad commanders than good ones.
What surprised me most
The Army Chief does not write like a hero.
He writes like an observer.
He openly narrates:
confusion
uncertainty
wrong assumptions
near-career failures
administrative frustrations
You realise senior leadership is less cinematic and more human.
So why the controversy?
Because readers search for confirmation.
If someone wants anti-government lines — they’ll find them.
If someone wants pro-government lines — they’ll find them.
But the book itself is neither.
It is actually about institutional reality, not politics.
Why you should read it
Not for war stories
Not for politics
Read it if you want to understand:
how national decisions actually get made
why systems move slowly
why leadership at top is lonely
how large organisations function under uncertainty
and how professionals think without ideological filters
In short —
This book explains India more than it explains the Army.
Final view
Four Stars of Destiny is not explosive.
It is revealing.
Not revealing secrets —
Revealing processes.
After reading it, instead of anger you mostly feel perspective.
And that is probably why people react strongly —
because it removes simple narratives.
No comments:
Post a Comment